This list will be researched more in the future, but it will be hard to confirm without pictures or video (even from high school or a school they may have transferred from/to), especially for the backups. Please contact me if you know of any others that have been on an official roster.
| Name | Seasons | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Trey DiCarlo | 2002-2004 | K |
| Tim Duncan | 1999-2001 | PK |
| Luke Elzinga | 2023-2024 | P |
| Cody Freeby | 2003-2005 | P |
| Montford Johnson | 1969-1970 | S |
| Tate Sandell | 2025-2025 | K |
| Tress Way | 2008-2012 | P |